|
UTILIZATION
OF RESULTS
The results of this research project are intended to aid the developers
of radiant simulation modules. The data, from over a 2-year period,
will provide a baseline from which simulation results can be compared.
There are sufficient envelope, system and climate data points to
make reasonable determinations as to the accuracy of the simulation
model.
Already, two thesis projects have utilized the Carefree performance
data to make comparisons with the results of the developing Energy
Plus radiant module. They have identified areas that need further
module development that will be the subject of ASHRAE papers.
CONTROL STRATEGY
At the Carefree facility, there are other refinements to the control
strategy that could be investigated. Can the floor panel (along
with a dehumidification system) alone be used to cool the house
during a Phoenix summer? What temperature of floor would best shift
the load to off-peak. Refinements after two more seasons of operation
should optimize the performance of the Carefree house.
DEVELOP A STANDARD CONTROL SYSTEM PACKAGE
For year round control of heating, cooling, ventilation and dehumidification,
develop a hardware and software package for radiant/convective systems.
Hardware is currently available, but it is usually sized for larger
commercial work (although this is required for the larger homes
today). Simplify the system requirements. Work to reduce the number
of sensors. When this project started, it was intended to use an
operative temperature sensor that was under development, but that
device did not materialize. Recently, a room operative temperature
sensor, with radio frequency transmission rather than being hard
wired, has appeared in the European market (Olesen 2001). These
small units are mobile and can be located near the occupant, say
on a table. Besides measuring the operative temperature, it can
be set for the desired temperature. In the Carefree house, a single
unit in each zone could replace 4 sensors. Viewing the data on floor
temperatures, it appears that maintaining a floor surface temperature
in the range of 71-73°F throughout the year may simplify some
aspects of the control system.
DEVELOP THE "SEASONAL TEMPERATURE" SENSOR
The seasonal temperature has proven to be a good indicator for making
control decisions at the Carefree house. It provides a close approximation
of the average daily temperature over the past 24 hours. Burying
a sensor in a "standard mass" would be worth considering
for the more complex residential and small commercial control systems
as a reference temperature, and the basis of making decisions. Devising
a standard "seasonal temperature mass" is suggested. It
could be prefabricated of concrete, with a sensor buried inside,
and brought to the site, Or it could be built on site to a standard
specification and incorporated in the structure.
FURTHER COMFORT LAB RESEARCH
Maybe more comfort lab testing should be considered. Lab tests up
to now have controlled space conditions by supply air. Maybe different
results could be obtained if surface temperatures were controlled,
as in a passive situation or as would be found with a year round
radiant heating and cooling system. In summer conditions, frequently
the ceiling is warmer than other surfaces.
DEVELOP RADIANT/CONVECTIVE SIMULATION TOOL
Further work is needed to produce a usable radiant/convective simulation
tool. The existing EnergyPlus tool showed good results in predicting
passive performance, but the active radiant system module needs
further development iterations, particularly related to defining
the various components that might be utilized. The lack of such
a user friendly tool is probably the biggest hindrance to the design
and specifying of radiant systems. The radiant industry should help
fund the tool's development.
FURTHER DEMONSTRATION
Construct a follow-on demonstration residence (or small commercial
building) utilizing lessons learned from the Carefree project. Experiment
with various methods of active thermal storage. Walls using insulated
concrete forms (ICF), but removing the interior forms after the
concrete is set may have some promise.
|